BRONX | Khiry Shelton couldn’t have picked a better time to score his first-ever goal in Major League Soccer.
The New York City FC rookie forward found the back of the net in the 91st minute as the Club rallied from a two-goal deficit while down a man to tie the Chicago Fire 2-2 in front of a raucous crowd of 23,315 on Friday night at Yankee Stadium.
New York City FC improves to 1-6-4 (7 points), while the Fire are now 3-5-1 (10 points).
Less than one minute after the fourth official signaled there would be a minimum of five minutes of stoppage time, Shelton and New York City FC turned a potential fifth-straight defeat into a well-deserved draw.
Captain David Villa slipped the ball to his left to Shelton who aimed toward the far post and slotted it home past a diving Sean Johnson.
The evening began as a potential repeat performance when the two sides met in Chicago on April 24.
New York City FC gave up the first goal in both matches and was limited to 10 men early in the first half.
On Friday, defender RJ Allen was pickpocketed by David Accam, but his tackle from behind on the Designated Player in the box resulted in a penalty kick and ejection in the 26th minute.
Jeff Larentowicz buried home the kick to give the visitors a two-goal advantage one minute later.
Unlike the 1-0 defeat at Toyota Park less than a month ago, New York City FC found not just one answer, but two.
The first came on the cusp of halftime.
Villa showed lovely control on a ball over the top before rifling an attempt from outside of the box on net. Johnson made the save but it went into a dangerous area as Mehdi Ballouchy put home the rebound in the 45th minute to cut the deficit to 2-1 at halftime.
New York City FC came out the stronger side in the second half, pressuring Johnson and the Chicago back line.
One minute into the second half, Andrew Jacobson’s header went toward Patrick Mullins and the ball ended up at Villa’s feet, but Johnson latched onto it.
In the 66th, defender Jeb Brovsky rushed onto a ball near the touchline and served up a cross to Villa, who controlled the pass and fired a shot on target. Villa had another opportunity to equalize four minutes later, but was tackled by Lovel Palmer was he was about to shoot and Johnson was able to gobble up the ball.
Chicago appeared to take a 1-0 lead in the seventh minute, but Shaun Maloney was called offsides.
The visitors broke the deadlock in the 14th with the Designated Player involved again. His cross from the left side was headed home by Razvan Cocis for a one-goal lead.
New York City FC head west for a match against head coach Jason Kreis’ former team, Real Salt Lake, on Friday, May 23. Kickoff from Rio Tinto Stadium is 10 p.m. EDT. The game will be broadcast on YES, WFAN, and WADO locally.